These blogs are the property, and trademark of Jordan Benzing, redistribution without prior consent, is not allowed.
Tuesday, April 3, 2012
Magicians:
Welcome to my nightmare: someone decided to merge C.S. Lewis, Harry Potter and a Porno. Frankly, I'm not sure if I should applaud, or tie a noose, throw it over a rafter and kick the chair out from under it.
This book came across my desk highly recommended by several friends and while the rhetoric was excellent, the grammar wonderful, and the scenery detailed, the plot line simply falls apart. Not only does it fall apart but it pulls from almost every Chronicle of Narnia book ever written including the frequently ignored Magician's Nephew.
We enter the life of a young boy named Quentin, the third weel, the genius in general the socially awkward odd one out. Gag me with a spoon, but I'm pretty sure thats how Harry Potter starts. Awkward kid with glasses who is constantly placed in socially awkward moments. Glancing over the parallel's, he is on his way to meet with someone to discuss his future attending Princeton college, things go catastrophically haywire, and he finds himself at a school for the magically gifted called "Brakebills" where he is examined poked and prodded until finally he is pushed into releasing some major spell-casting without intending too. Which depressingly the author never once decides to really describe magic at that level ever again until the very end of the book and even that scene lasts marginally longer than sex with the over-priced hooker you lost your virginity too.
SPOILER ALERT
Now let me begin this with the disclaimer that any author who has the balls to even begin to throw time travel into one of their books deserve's a pat on the back. In this case though I honestly have to say what the ever-living hell where you planning on doing with this one.
First of all, you have a character who is capable of time travel, who can go back in time and alter the past through the use of a silver watch given to her by some magic dwarves.
Second of all, the entire miserable excuse for a plot revolves around the fate of Martin Chatwin who has through some level of delusion decided that he is a god and kills of the other god's of Fillory assuming power and control of one of the apparently thousands of multi-verses.
Lastly, the kicker the character in possession of the watch who has gone back in time and tried "all of the possible outcomes" something the book claims is in an of itself impossible by its own rules, claims there is no other way for everything that has happened to Quentin and his friends to not happen and then destroy's the watch.
Conclusion: Essentially all powerful mages who have the ability to manipulate space time, and bring small animals to life were found to be incapable of going back in time, and killing one particular boy who broke the rules BEFORE he turned into the big bad wolf. Not only that, but the actual importance of the lives of these so called magicians is zero. The battle they fought was pointless, there world wasn't in danger their lives weren't in danger. No, they stuck their head inside of a giant death trap and slammed the thing shut on themeselves repeatedly until some of them DIED.
My overall rating for this book, is a two out of five, and the second star in that rating is a pity star thrown out there because the author decided to cause two of his characters to have animal sex.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment