Welcome to the internet, the age of a new kind of piracy, where no ones treasure is completely safe. Welcome to the age of the Grid, the digital download the world of 0's and 1's. The internet though is a dangerous place the digital world itself is something that both cloaks someone in anonymity while exposing them, making them as naked as the day they were born. This doesn't just apply to ones personal information it applies to there creations as well.
Yes, thats right I'm refering to those naughty people of the world that download music illegally or steal from artist's who pledge there heart and soul to making music.
When you download a song without paying for the song, in affect your doing the same thing that pirates of the ocean used to do. Travel along and rob people that were physically incapable of defending themselves. The only thing that makes us better than pirates of old, is that this new form of internet piracy doesn't physically harm anyone. The end result of the work is no longer death.
Because of the ease that comes with downloading information, what then is our ethical priority? Kantianism would state that all the arguments people make imply that the creator is mentally deficient by creating the argument of, "You don't want people to steal from you, and no one else wants to be stolen from therefore, we create the categorical imparitive of; No one should steal". Note that this argument states that NO one should steal. Not sometimes, not well you can steal if...
Most people don't subscribe to Kantianism though most subscribe either to virtue ethics, or situational ethics.
Virtue ethics again creates the idea that stealing is in and of itself feels wrong, or should feel wrong and therefore no one should do it.
Situation ethics is a different bear. Instead it dictates that based on your present situation you make the most loving choice. Which should still lead to no stealing.
Why then do people still steal music from online? The answer is simple, people feel that they don't have to pay to listen to music on the radio, or to have to listen to music on youtube. Then why should they have to pay to be able to listen to the music on their iPod?
Personally I think that the piracy of music and movies in the world today is something that is a great ethical challenge we face and indicates the depravity of our society. In fact what country that can't even properly defend the rights of its own people the singers and performers of the nation should have the right to meddle in other countries affairs?
No comments:
Post a Comment